Probate Litigation

Probate Litigation Attorney in Presque Isle County

Local Probate Litigation Counsel, Over 20 Years of Experience

When an estate becomes contested, the stakes are personal and the legal process is anything but routine. Probate litigation covers disputes over a will’s validity, the conduct of a personal representative or trustee, or the rights of beneficiaries and heirs. These cases move through the Presque Isle County Probate Court under Michigan’s Estates and Protected Individuals Code (EPIC), and the deadlines are strict. Attorney Katy Carignan brings over 20 years of practical legal experience, deep roots in Northeast Michigan, and a process that can be handled fully remote for clients across the region.

If you’re facing a contested estate or probate dispute in Presque Isle County, don’t wait to get guidance. Call us at (989) 623-7592 to discuss your situation.

Probate Disputes We Handle

Contested probate matters take several forms. We represent both those challenging an estate plan or fiduciary action and those defending against a challenge.

Will contests: Challenges to a will’s validity based on lack of testamentary capacity (the mental ability to make a valid will), undue influence, fraud, forgery, or improper execution under EPIC.
Trust disputes: Claims involving trustee mismanagement, self-dealing, or improper distributions from a trust.
Breach of fiduciary duty: Claims against a personal representative or trustee for mismanagement, conflicts of interest, or improper handling of estate assets. Remedies can include removal, surcharge, or damages.
Beneficiary and inheritance disputes: Conflicts among heirs over asset distribution, interpretation of will or trust language, or the actions of a fiduciary.
Contested guardianships and conservatorships: Disputes over the appointment, conduct, or removal of a guardian or conservator for a protected individual.

Why Presque Isle County Families Work with Carig Law

Probate litigation benefits from an attorney who knows the local court and the community. Our office is based in Rogers City, close to the Presque Isle County Courthouse, and our work extends throughout Northeast Michigan communities, including Onaway. That local familiarity matters when a case involves navigating court procedures, local family dynamics, or time-sensitive filings.

Katy Carignan has over 20 years of experience in estate and probate matters, and our approach centers on clear communication and solutions tailored to each client’s specific situation. One client, Bruce B., came to us after a prior attorney’s mistakes sent an estate into probate. He described working with our firm as quick and painless, which reflects how we handle even difficult probate situations. For clients who can’t easily travel to Rogers City, our entire process is available fully remote.

Talk to a Probate Litigation Lawyer in Presque Isle County

Probate disputes are time-sensitive. Missing a filing deadline under EPIC can bar your claim entirely, so reaching out early matters. We can listen to your situation, help you understand your options, and work with you on a path forward.

We serve clients throughout Northeast Michigan, and our process is fully remote if you need it. Call Carig Law at (989) 623-7592 to get started.

How Michigan Probate Litigation Works

Contested probate matters follow a defined process, though the timeline and complexity vary depending on the nature of the dispute. Here’s a general overview of what to expect.

Filing & Initial Objections

Probate litigation typically begins when a party files a petition or formal objection with the probate court. Will contests are often required before the will is admitted to probate, though specific deadlines depend on whether the proceeding is formal or informal. Acting early preserves your rights and gives time to assess the strength of a claim before it becomes urgent.

Discovery

The discovery phase involves gathering evidence to support or defend the dispute. In will contests, that often means medical records, financial documents, correspondence, and witness testimony relevant to testamentary capacity or undue influence claims.

Mediation

Michigan probate courts often encourage mediation before a matter goes to trial. Mediation can resolve disputes faster, at lower cost, and with less strain on family relationships than a full evidentiary hearing. When a negotiated resolution is possible, it’s worth pursuing seriously.

Hearing or Trial

If mediation doesn’t resolve the matter, the case proceeds to an evidentiary hearing or trial before a probate judge. The judge weighs the evidence and testimony to reach a decision. Adverse rulings can be challenged through the Michigan Court of Appeals.

Deadlines in Michigan Probate Litigation

EPIC sets strict timeframes for probate litigation claims, and missing them can permanently bar a challenge. General timelines to be aware of include the following, though you should consult an attorney about deadlines specific to your situation.

Will contest window: Interested persons generally have 63 days after receiving formal notice of a personal representative’s appointment, or 4 months after publication of notice to creditors, to file a contest.
Trust and fiduciary claims: Trust disputes and breach of fiduciary duty claims carry their own statutes of limitations, which vary by claim type.
Decedent’s causes of action: EPIC extends the statute of limitations on causes of action that belonged to the decedent to a minimum of 12 months after the date of death.

Acting early gives an attorney time to gather evidence, evaluate the case, and explore pre-litigation resolution where it’s possible. The longer a dispute sits unaddressed, the narrower the options become.

Contact Us Today

At Carig Law, we're always ready to take your call! Give us a call at (989) 623-7592 or fill out the form below to contact one of our team members.

First Name
Last Name
Phone
Email
Are you a new client?
How can we help you?
By submitting, you agree to receive text messages from Carig Law at the number provided, including those related to your inquiry, follow-ups, and review requests, via automated technology. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Msg frequency may vary. Reply STOP to cancel or HELP for assistance. Acceptable Use Policy

Real People, Real Peace of Mind.

Honest Feedback from People We’ve Had the Privilege to Help.

Why Choose Carig Law?

Client-Focused Service
We focus on building trust and long-term client relationships. Many clients return because they feel heard, respected, and supported.
Tailored Legal Strategies
Rather than a “one-size-fits-all” approach, the firm specializes and customizes solutions that fit each client’s specific life, goals, and circumstances.
Flexible Legal Support

For clients with medical constraints, Carig Law offers flexible meeting options, prioritizing client convenience and comfort.
Expedited Services Available

For urgent situations, Carig Law can expedite steps (in some cases, completing matters in a single day) to ensure clients receive critical help.

How to Get Started? We’re here to listen and help you understand your next step.